OT:RR:CTF:VS ME
Dinesh Melwani
Mintz, Levin, Cohn, Ferris, Glovsky and Popeo, P.C.
1 Financial Center
Boston, MA 02111
RE: Applicability of Subheading 9810.00.35, HTSUS; Joy Box and Feel Better Bag
Dear Mr. Melwani:
The following is our decision regarding your ruling request submitted on August 12,
2025, on behalf of Spread the Joy Inc., (“Spread the Joy”) to U.S. Customs and Border
Protection (“CBP”), National Commodity Specialist Division (“NCSD”). The request was
forwarded to the Valuation and Special Programs Branch on October 20, 2025, for a decision on
the applicability of subheading 9810.00.35, Harmonized Tariff Schedule of the United States
(“HTSUS”), to the Joy Box and Feel Better Bag.
FACTS:
Spread the Joy is a U.S.-based non-profit that supplies its Joy Boxes and Feel Better Bags
to over 350 hospitals and medical providers in the United States. Spread the Joy’s website states
that as an organization, its activity kits are delivered to children’s bedsides in the hospital and
they are filled with therapeutic arts-and-crafts to lift their spirits through play. 1 An excel file was
provided listing over 350 medical providers, some of which are not for profit or public, but some
are for profit. The items are provided free of charge to children in long-term pediatric care, and
are not sold commercially. Counsel claims that the items are intended for educational use for
children who cannot attend traditional classroom instruction while hospitalized. Counsel states
that the “Feel Better Bags and Joy Boxes are expertly designed by child life specialists,
1
www.spreadthejoy.org
1
therapists, parents, and, most importantly, children. The program has been tested against the five
pillars of patient experience—play, normalization, socialization, emotional support, and
procedural support—and Joy Boxes and Feel Better Bags are 100% clinician approved.”
The Feel Better Bag contains 11 elements and will be assembled abroad and imported as one
single item. Each Feel Better Bag contains the following:
• A 70-page “Feel Better Bag Activity Booklet,” with activities that accompany the other
items. The booklet contains sections on conversational prompts, origami instructions,
jokes, doodles, clay projects, magic tricks, and written games like tic-tac-toe,
• Multiple sheets of colorful origami paper,
• A “finger eye” fidget toy,
• An “Extra Large Cootie Catcher” paper model,
• Air-dry putty containers,
• A deck of 54 “Would You Rather” playing cards,
• Six positive quote coloring posters,
• Two paint brushes and 10 bright 5ml paint pots,
• A 6-in-1 marker,
• 15 “Super Cool Stickers” of various shapes, and
• A thin canvas for painting and drawing.
Similarly, the Joy Box contains 20 elements. Unlike the Feel Better Bag, Spread the Joy
indicates that each box element would be imported individually and assembled in the United
States by a team of volunteers, before being distributed at hospitals. Each Joy Box contains the
following:
• A 126-page “Book of Joy Activity Booklet” with activities that accompany the other
items (the booklet contains sections on drawing, painting, music, magic, origami,
meditation, jokes, paper crafts, fun facts, clay projects, game instructions, and
instructions on how to build a model wooden plane),
• A stress ball,
• A “finger eye” fidget toy,
• A wooden model plane,
• “Let’s Talk Conversation Cards,” with various conversation prompts,
• A deck of 54 “Would You Rather” playing cards,
• A magic trick card,
• Six positive quote coloring posters,
• An “Extra Large Cootie Catcher” paper model,
• A dog plush toy,
• A two-pack of hair bands,
• Ludo & Dice Race game board,
• Game pieces and dice for the board game,
• 15 “Super Cool Stickers” of various shapes,
• A “Gratitude Tree” printed poster,
• A thin canvas for painting and drawing,
2
• Two paint brushes and 13 bright 5ml paint pots,
• A 12-pack of markers,
• Multiple sheets of colorful origami paper, and
• 15 “Super Cool Stickers” of various shapes.
ISSUE:
Whether the Feel Better Bag and Joy Box items qualify for duty-free treatment under
subheading 9810.00.35, HTSUS.
LAW AND ANALYSIS:
Subheading 9810.00.35, HTSUS, came into effect in the United States through a series of
international agreements and acts of Congress. Its basis is in the Agreement on the Importation
of Educational, Scientific and Cultural Materials, opened for signature Nov. 22, 1950, 17 U.S.T.
1835, 131 U.N.T.S. 25, or Florence Agreement, drafted by the United Nations Educational,
Scientific, and Cultural Organization (“UNESCO”) in July 1950. The subheading provides for:
“Articles imported for the use of any public library, any other public institution or any nonprofit
institution established for educational, scientific, literary or philosophical purposes, or for the
encouragement of the fine arts.” Subheading 9810.00.35, HTSUS is restricted to the following
enumerated articles listed in the provision:
“Letters, numbers, and other symbols; number cards and other arithmetical materials;
printed matter; blocks and other dimensional shapes; geometrical figures, plane or solid;
geographical globes; tuned bells and basic materials for understanding music; model
articles and figures of animate objects; puzzles and games; flags; dressing frames;
dummy clocks; bottles, boxes, and other containers or holders; all the foregoing, whether
or not in sets, fabricated to specification and designed for the classroom instruction of
children; and containers or holders fabricated to specification and designed for the
storage of such instructional articles when not in use.”
U.S. Note 1 to Subchapter X, Chapter 98, HTSUS, provides in pertinent part: “Except as
provided in subheading 9810.00.20…, or as otherwise provided for in this U.S. Note, the articles
covered by this subchapter must be exclusively for the use of the institutions involved, and not
for distribution, sale or other commercial use within 5 years after being entered. Articles
admitted under any provision in this subchapter may be transferred from an institution specified
with respect to such articles to another such institution, or may be exported or destroyed under
customs supervision, without duty liability being incurred. However, if any such article (other
than an article provided for in subheading 9810.00.20 or subheading 9810.00.70) is transferred
other than as provided by the preceding sentence, or is used for commercial purposes, within 5
years after being entered, the institution for which such article was entered shall promptly notify
customs officers at the port of entry and shall be liable for the payment of duty on such article in
an amount determined on the basis of its condition as imported and the rate applicable to it
(determined without regard to this subchapter) when entered.”
3
CBP has previously ruled that in order to qualify for duty-free treatment under
subheading 9810.00.35, HTSUS, the products must be imported by a “qualified institution or its
agent pursuant to a pre-existing order for the merchandise.” See Headquarters Ruling (“HQ”)
555483, dated April 11, 1990; and New York Ruling (“NY”) N304676 dated June 28, 2019.
Here, both the box and bag are imported not necessarily for the use of Spread the Joy, as an
organization, but for hospitals, some of which are for profit. Therefore, the articles will not in all
instances meet the requirement that the articles are for use of nonprofit institutions established
for educational, scientific, literary or philosophical purposes, or for the encouragement of the
fine arts. While Spread the Joy argues that it is a nonprofit established for educational purposes,
and that its mission is to “provide[] hospitalized children with boxes designed to entertain,
educate, and [] spark joy,” the articles actually are used by the various hospitals.
Another issue here is whether the articles themselves fall within the provision.
Subheading 9810.00.35, HTSUS, specifically requires that the items being imported must be
“fabricated to specification and designed for the classroom instruction of children” (emphasis
added). The Feel Better Bag and Joy Box are specifically designed for Spread the Joy’s hospital
program, and will only be used for that purpose. The U.S. Department of Education’s National
Center for Education Statistics has defined instruction in elementary and secondary school as
encompassing “all activities dealing directly with the interaction between teachers and
students.” 2 Here, there is no teacher. The items are provided directly to the children absent any
oversight, interaction, or assistance of an instructor. Classroom instruction also implies the
existence of a structured learning environment, such as a school or a class, whether in person or
virtual. This is not the case here. The products are not part of any organized curriculum used in
school, hospital education programs, or any classroom setting. Spread the Joy states that the Feel
Better Bag and Joy Box are “used for educational purposes for patients in long-term pediatric
care and thus unable to attend traditional classroom instruction.” Whether the products have
educational value is a separate question from whether they are designed for the “classroom
instruction of children.” Many toys such as LEGO, jigsaw puzzles, or some video games, are
used for educational purposes, even though they are not specifically designed for use in a
classroom. Spread the Joy, while arguably educational, is simply not engaged in the direct
classroom instruction of children, nor has it provided any evidence that its partner hospitals will
use its products for the classroom instruction of children. Therefore, its specially designed
products are not “fabricated to specification and designed for the classroom instruction of
children.”
We also note that some of the items, such as the plush toy, hair bands, markers, stress
ball, and origami paper, do not appear uniquely designed for the classroom instruction of
children, and Spread the Joy has not provided evidence that the manufacturer intended for them
to be used primarily in the classroom. Accordingly, we also do not believe that any of the
individually imported items qualify for duty-free treatment under 9810.00.35, HTSUS.
2
“Digest of Education Statistics: 2022,” National Center for Education Statistics, (accessed July 2, 2026),
(https://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d22/app_b.asp.).
4
HOLDING:
Based upon the information submitted, the Feel Better Bags and items for the Joy Boxes
are not eligible for duty-free treatment under subheading 9810.00.35, HTSUS.
Sincerely,
Monika R. Brenner, Chief
Valuation and Special Programs Branch
5