CLA-2 RR:CR:GC 959308 MMC
Port Director of Customs
Hemisphere Center
Routes 1& 9 South, Room 200
Newark, New Jersey 07114
RE: IA 20/96; Sculptstone Cow Statuette
Dear Port Director:
This is in response to a May 13, 1996, memorandum (CLA-2-NEW:TCBII:204) from the Process Owner, Trade Compliance Division,
New York, Newark Area, to the Director of the National Commodity
Specialist Division, requesting internal advice concerning the
classification of a sculptstone cow statuette under the
Harmonized Tariff Schedule of the United States (HTSUS). A
sample was submitted with the request. In preparing the decision
consideration was given to the views of counsel for the importer
as expressed in a June 17, 1997, meeting and a June 25, 1997,
supplemental submission.
FACTS:
The subject article, identified as item number 14311, is a
sculptstone statuette depicting a Holstein cow. The article
measures 2«" high and approximately 3 " long. The statuette has
been painted white with irregular black patches. It has pink
shadowing on the inside of the ears, mouth, snout and utter. A
bell is attached around the cow's neck.
On page 9 of the Russ Berrie and Company, Inc., "Wishes and
Whimys" catalog the article is depicted under the title "Cow
Mania." The particular article is identified as "Cow Belles."
According to the catalog the article can be purchased in
different designs/ stances in assortments. The box is labeled
"Cowbelles collectible figurine dancing cow." All articles in
the catalog are individually gift boxed.
Counsel asserts that the statuette is classifiable under the
1996 subheading 9503.41.0030, HTSUS, which provides for "Other
toys; reduced-size ("scale") models and similar recreational
models, working or not; puzzles of all kinds; parts and
accessories thereof: Toys representing animals or non-human
creatures (for example, robots and monsters) and parts and
accessories thereof: Stuffed toys and parts and accessories
thereof: Other." The headings under consideration are as
follows:
6810 Articles of cement, of concrete or of artificial
stone, whether or not reinforced
9503 Other toys; reduced-size ("scale") models and
similar recreational models, working or not;
puzzles of all kinds; parts and accessories
thereof
ISSUE:
Whether the sculptstone cow statuette is classifiable as an
agglomerated stone statuette or as a toy.
LAW AND ANALYSIS:
Classification under the HTSUS is made in accordance with
the General Rules of Interpretation (GRIs). GRI 1 provides that
the classification of goods shall be determined according to the
terms of the headings of the tariff schedule and any relative
section or chapter notes. In the event that the goods cannot be
classified solely on the basis of GRI 1, and if the headings and
legal notes do not otherwise require, the remaining GRI may then
be applied.
Heading 6810, HTSUS, provides for articles of cement, of
concrete or of artificial
stone, whether or not reinforced. In understanding the language
of the HTSUS, the Explanatory Notes (ENs) of the Harmonized
Commodity Description and Coding System may be utilized. The
ENs, although not dispositive, or legally binding, provide a
commentary on the scope of each heading, and are generally
indicative of the proper interpretation of the HTSUS. See, T.D.
89-90, 54 Fed. Reg. 35127, 35128 (August 23, 1989). EN 68.10
states, in pertinent part, that:
This heading covers moulded, pressed or centrifuged articles
(e.g., certain pipes) of cement (including slag cement), of
concrete or of artificial stone...
* * *
Artificial stone is an imitation of natural stone obtained
by agglomerating pieces of natural stone or crushed or
powdered natural stone (limestone, marble, granite,
porphyry, serpentine, etc.) with lime or cement or other
binders (e.g., plastics). Articles of artificial stone
include those of "terrazzo", "granito", etc.
* * *
The heading includes, inter alia, ... vases, flower-pots,
architectural or garden ornaments; statues, statuettes,
animal figures; ornamental goods. [emphasis added]
* * *
The articles of this heading may be bushed, ground,
polished, varnished, bronzed, enamelled, made to imitate
slate, moulded or otherwise ornamented, coloured in the
mass, reinforced with metal, etc. (e.g., reinforced or
pre-stressed concrete), or fitted with accessories of other
materials (e.g., hinges, etc.)....
As animal statuettes are specifically enumerated in the ENs, the
cow statuettes are clearly described by heading 6810, HTSUS.
Counsel has suggested that while the cow statuettes may meet
the description of heading 6810, HTSUS, they are nonetheless
excluded from classification in heading 6810 by operation of Note
1(l) to Chapter 68, which excludes from classification in Chapter
68, "Articles of Chapter 95 (for example, toys, games and sports
equipment)."
Heading 9503 provides, in pertinent part, for toys as well
as their parts and accessories. The ENs to Chapter 95 indicate
that the chapter covers toys of all kinds, whether designed for
the amusement of children or adults. The phrase "designed for
the amusement of" is generally understood to indicate that the
article is principally used and designed for amusement.
Because Chapter 95 provides for articles which are classifiable
according to the use of the class or kind of goods to which they
belong, Additional U.S. Rule of Interpretation 1(a), HTSUS, is
applicable.
Additional U.S. Rule of Interpretation 1(a) provides that in
the absence of special language or context which otherwise
requires, a tariff classification controlled by use (other than
actual use) is to be determined in accordance with the use in the
United States at, or immediately prior to, the date of
importation, of goods of that class or kind to which the imported
goods belong, and the controlling use is the principal use. In
other words, the article's principal use at the time of
importation determines whether it is classifiable within a
particular class or kind.
While Additional U.S. Rule of Interpretation 1(a) provides
general criteria for discerning the principal use of an article,
the U.S. Court of International Trade (CIT) has provided factors,
which are indicative but not conclusive, to apply when
determining whether merchandise falls within a particular class
or kind. They include: general physical characteristics, the
expectation of the ultimate purchaser, channels of trade,
environment of sale (accompanying accessories, manner of
advertisement and display), use in the same manner as merchandise
which defines the class, economic practicality of so using the
import, and recognition in the trade of this use. See: Kraft,
Inc, v. United States, USITR, 16 CIT 483, (June 24,
1992)(hereinafter Kraft); G. Heilman Brewing Co. v. United
States, USITR, 14 CIT 614 (Sept. 6, 1990); and United States v.
Carborundum Company, 63 CCPA 98, C.A.D. 1172, 536 F. 2d 373
(1976), cert. denied, 429 U.S. 979.
As is abundantly demonstrated in the importer's catalog,
sculptstone, the cow statuette's constituent material, is one
which is commonly used for decorative statuettes. Additionally,
evidence has been presented that these articles environment of
sale will be card and gift shops, a typical venue for decorative
statuettes. Moreover, the articles are marketed as home
decorative statuettes in such magazines as Elle Decor, Better
Homes and Gardens, Martha Stewart's Living, Metropolitan Home,
Midwest Living, Country Living and Woman's Day. Furthermore,
they move in a channel of trade for gift shop decorative
articles. These facts lead us to believe that the expectation of
the ultimate purchaser of the cow statuette would be to use them
as decorative display pieces. Finally, these factors do not
indicate that the article belongs to the class or kind "toy", but
rather to the class or kind " statuette."
In support of its contention that the cow statuette belongs
to the class or kind "toy", counsel asserts that the cow
statuette's physical characteristics indicate that it is
"primarily designed to amuse." Citing Headquarters Ruling
Letter (HRL) 953186 dated April 13, 1993, counsel claims that
this ruling indicates the an article's humorous facial features,
its posture and its general attire can suggest "personality" and
provide amusement therefore making an article classifiable as a
toy. HRL 953186 concerned a fully stuffed bear measuring 6
inches high in a sitting position sewn to a stuffed chair. In
the ruling a conclusion was drawn that the article was amusing.
No analysis was provided for the conclusion. Specifically, there
was no discussion of facial features, attire, or personality
providing amusement.
HRL 088928 dated September 6, 1991, which classified a
plastic horse as a toy for tariff purposes, is also cited
claiming that the ruling indicates that a lack of finely detailed
features on a statuette indicates that it is classifiable as a
toy rather than a statuette. While the ruling does mention a
lack of finely detailed features, that factor was by no means the
sole consideration for the determination that the article was a
toy. HRL 088928 concerned the classification of a PVC plastic
horse statuette blister packaged together with a saddle, blanket,
bridle, brushes and feed box, all to scale. We held that its PVC
plastic construction, lack of fine detail, packaging and overall
appearance was not consistent with items not principally used as
decorative statuettes. The accessories sold with the article
seemed clearly designed to provide additional amusement.
Moreover, the blister packaging was a common packaging method
for toys and not seen for decorative items.
Applied to the present cow statuette, these same criteria
clearly indicate that the article is principally used as a
decorative statuette. It is true that the article may have what
one could describe as an "amusing" expression and is not as
detailed as other statuettes. However, as it abundantly evident
from several of the importer's catalogs, the article's
constituent material and packaging are of the kind quite commonly
used for decorative statuettes. The cow statuettes are packaged
and sold in individual boxes, a packaging practice common to the
decorative statuette market; not the toy market. We note as well
that the box is labeled "Cowbelles collectible figurine dancing
cow." This is a clear indication that the article is intended to
be sold as a decorative statuette. Finally, the articles are
sold in a venue, card and gift shops and as "collectables", which
are both indicative the ultimate purchaser's intent to use the
cow statuettes as decorative statuettes, not toys.
Finally, counsel cites three cases decided under the Tariff
Schedule of the United States (TSUS). Congress has indicated
that earlier tariff decisions must not be disregarded in applying
the HTSUS. The conference report to the Omnibus Trade Bill of
1988, states that "on a case-by-case basis prior decisions should
be considered instructive in interpreting the HTS[US],
particularly where the nomenclature previously interpreted in
those decisions remains unchanged and no dissimilar
interpretation is required by the text of the HTS[US]." H. Rep.
No. 100-576, 100th cong., 2d Sess. 548, 550 (1988).
It is asserted that the cow statuettes are toys because they
provide the same kind of "frivolous amusement" that playthings
give. In support of the position, counsel cites The United
States v. Topps Chewing Gum Inc., 58 CCPA 157, C.A.D. 1022
(1971), (hereinafter Topps) which concerned the classification of
various decorative buttons with humorous quotes. Topps held that
if the purpose of an object is to give the same kind of enjoyment
as playthings give, its purpose is amusement. It is the quality
of mind or emotion induced by the object which is controlling.
Therefore, an article classified as a toy does not have to be a
plaything, provided that the quality of emotion induced by the
article takes on the character of frivolous amusement. We are of
the opinion that the reasoning provided for in Topps is not
applicable to the present article. In Topps, the court
classified articles whose humorous sayings created evident and
inherent amusement. This is not the case with the cow
statuettes. Nothing about them is inherently or evidently
amusing.
According to counsel, the court in Rene D. Lyon Co., Inc.
v. United States, 80 Cust. Ct. 39, C.D. 4735 (1978) (Lyons)
found that miniature animal figures were given human attributes
which were well suited to create amusement because they were
comical in appearance and that this fact militated against the
importer's contention that the articles were not toys. In Lyons
as in all classification cases, the Customs classification, which
was as a toy, was presumed to be correct. The importer had the
legal burden of proving that Customs classification was incorrect
and that its claimed classification of either Christmas ornaments
or other plastic articles was correct. No claim of plastic
statuette was made as a possible alternative, even though such a
category existed in 1978.
The court found that the importer defendant did not provide
enough evidence that either of its claimed classifications was
the correct one, nor did the importer offer any evidence that the
classification of toy was incorrect. The merits of the
classification of the statuettes as toys was not addressed nor
was the possibility of the alternative classification as a
statuette. As the case addresses neither of these issues and was
issued under the TSUS, it has little if any precedential value
concerning the subject merchandise.
Finally, counsel asserts that its articles are collectables
and that "collecting" by adults is a form of amusement. In
support of this proposition, he cites Artmark Chicago, LTD. v.
United States, 76 Cust.Ct. 187, C.D. 4654 (1976) aff'd. 64
C.C.P.A.116, 558 F.2d 600, C.A.D. 1192 (1977) (Artmark).
Artmark concerned the classification of a plastic horse similar
to that in HRL 088928, claiming the article was classifiable as a
plastic statuette. Customs classified it as a toy. While the
importer did examine an expert witness who stated that collecting
articles as a hobby by adults, was in his opinion, a form of
amusement, the merit of such a conclusion was not a consideration
nor was it even addressed in the court's determination. Rather,
the court held that the importer had not meet its burden of
proving Customs classification as a toy was incorrect, because it
presented evidence about the manner of sale which only applied to
a restricted area of the U.S.. Additionally, the court held that
the chief use of an article is a question of fact which must be
established on the basis of positive testimony representing such
use throughout the U.S. and that such use must relate to the
particular class or kind of article involved at or immediately
prior to the time of importation. As the validity of the cited
comment was not addressed and the case was issued under the TSUS,
it has little if any precedential value concerning the subject
merchandise.
Heading 9503, HTSUS, does not describe the cow statuettes.
Therefore, the artificial stone animal figures are classifiable
under subheading 6810.99.00, which provides for articles of
cement, of concrete or of artificial stone, whether or not
reinforced: Other articles: Other.
HOLDING:
The sculptstone cow statuette is classifiable under
subheading 6810.99.00, which provides for articles of cement, of
concrete or of artificial stone, whether or not reinforced: Other
articles: Other, with a general 1997 column one duty rate of 2
percent ad valorem.
This decision should be mailed by your office to counsel no
later than 60 days from the date of this letter. On that date,
the Office of Regulations and Rulings will take steps to make the
decision available to Customs personnel via the Customs Rulings
Module in ACS and the public via the Diskette Subscription
Service, Freedom of Information Act and other public access
channels.
Sincerely,
John Durant, Director
Commercial Rulings Division