CLA CO:R:C:T 952112 BC
TARIFF: 4202.12.2020
Mitch Spratford
Vice President - Marketing
PLANO Molding Company
Plano, Illinois 60545-0189
RE: Request for classification; subheading 4202.12.2020, HTSUSA;
plastic cosmetic and accessory organizer cases; vanity cases;
Caboodles
Dear Mr. Spratford:
This responds to your letter of June 25, 1992, requesting a
classification ruling for three products marketed and sold by
your company as "Caboodles." These are cosmetic and accessory
organizers. Samples were provided for examination.
FACTS:
You provided a product catalog entitled "Caboodles."
Therein, "Caboodles" are described as cosmetic and accessory
organizers. The catalog contains seven pages of "Caboodles" of
various sizes, shapes, colors, and features. There is the
"Designer" series, the "Signature" series, the "Custom" series,
the "Specialty" series, and the "Jewelry" series. Each series
includes several designs. While sizes, colors, shapes, and
features differ somewhat among and within the various series, all
"Caboodles" are molded plastic cases with a top that opens upward
and snaps closed. Inside the cases are compartments and/or trays
that are used for storing small items; the main compartment is in
the base of the case. Depending on the style observed, the trays
and compartments either swing up as the case is opened, are
removable, and/or slide out or over for convenient storage. Many
cases contain small mirrors. Every page of the catalog pictures
cases holding cosmetics and/or jewelry. The cases have handles
on the top (for carrying) and are designed to be portable. Three
pages of the catalog picture a young woman carrying a "Caboodle"
case with other luggage. The sample has a sticker affixed to the
outside top with the words, "Beauty Face Vanity Case."
Your request specifies three model types: the 2610, 2622,
and 2640, all approximately the same size (the 2640 is the
largest at approximately 14"x9"x7"). Samples of these were
examined. All models fit the above general description. You
have asserted that these cases should be classified under
4202.12.2020, Harmonized Tariff Schedule of the United States
Annotated (HTSUSA).
ISSUE:
What is the classification of the three "Caboodle" cases
designated as model numbers 2610, 2622, and 2640?
LAW AND ANALYSIS:
Classification under the Harmonized Tariff Schedule of the
United States Annotated (HTSUSA) is governed by the General Rules
of Interpretation (GRI). GRI 1 provides that classification is
determined in accordance with the terms of the headings and any
relative section or chapter notes. Where goods cannot be
classified solely on the basis of GRI 1, the remaining rules will
be applied in sequential order.
You assert that the three "Caboodle" cases should be
classified under 4202.12.2020, HTSUSA. We agree. Heading 4202,
HTSUSA, provides for the classification of "Trunks, suitcases,
vanity cases, attache cases, brief cases, school satchels,
spectacle cases, binocular cases, . . . [etc.]." The definition
of "vanity case" is as follows: "A small handbag or case for
carrying cosmetics or toiletries [emphasis supplied]." Webster's
II New Riverside University Dictionary, (1984), p. 1276. Given
that the cases in question are clearly vanity cases, heading 4202
is an eo nomine provision covering the submitted samples.
Subheading 4202.12.2020, HTSUSA, covers "Trunks, suitcases,
vanity cases, attache cases, briefcases, school satchels and
similar containers: With outer surface of plastics or of textile
materials: With outer surface of plastics . . . Structured, rigid
on all sides: Trunks suitcases, vanity cases and similar
containers . . ." The current Column 1 duty rate is 20% ad
valorem.
In support of the foregoing is HQ 951404, dated July 24,
1992. That case affirmed New York Ruling 870044 which classified
vanity cases under heading 4202, HTSUSA. The cases considered in
HQ 951404 are remarkably similar to the "Caboodles" involved in
the instant case. One of them (considered in HQ 951404) had the
same dimensions, features (including the sticker "Beauty Face
Vanity Case" on the top of the case), and model number (molded
into the bottom of the case) as one of the "Caboodles." HQ
951404 rejected classification of the vanity cases in heading
3923, HTSUSA, in part, on the grounds that Note 2(h) of Chapter
39, HTSUSA, excludes from that chapter containers of heading
4202. Since we had determined (in HQ 951404) the cases to be
vanity cases, the exclusion of Note 2(h) was conclusive. See HQ
087635 (October 24, 1990) for our classification of a lunch
box/cooler in heading 4202 rather than heading 3923; see also HQ
951738 (August 11, 1992) for a similar discussion regarding
plastic tackle boxes and rejection of heading 9507 in addition to
heading 3923.
HOLDING:
The "Caboodles," or cosmetic and accessory organizer cases,
in question are classified under subheading 4202.12.2020, HTSUSA,
as vanity cases or similar containers made of molded plastic,
structured and rigid on all sides. The applicable Column 1 rate
of duty is 20% ad valorem.
Sincerely,
John Durant, Director
Commercial Rulings Division