VES-3/10-02-RR:IT:EC 113856 GEV
D. Lee Roberts, Jr., Esq.
Ware, Snow, Fogel, Jackson & Greene, P.C.
570 Tower Place
3340 Peachtree Road, N.E.
Atlanta, Georgia 30326
RE: COLUMBUS; Coastwise Trade; Dredging; Transportation of
Dredge Material; Value;
First Proviso; 46 U.S.C. App. 292, 883; Pub. L. 102-587
Dear Mr. Roberts:
This is in response to your letter of February 20, 1997, on
behalf of your client, Lake Michigan Contractors, Inc. ("Lake
Michigan"), of Holland, Michigan, requesting a ruling regarding
the use of the vessel COLUMBUS in a maintenance dredging
operation conducted in Cleveland Harbor and the Cuyahoga River in
Ohio. Our ruling on this matter is set forth below.
FACTS:
A solicitation to dredge the harbor in the Port of Cleveland
and the Cuyahoga River in the State of Ohio was issued by the
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Buffalo, N.Y. District, on December
16, 1996. The work in question, described in the solicitation
offer as being set aside for small business, includes the removal
and disposal of approximately 150,000 cubic yards of dredged
material from the channels of Cleveland Harbor and the Cuyahoga
River. Pursuant to the terms of the solicitation offer,
subsequent to its removal from the bottom of these channels this
material is to be transported to either the Government-furnished
Confined Disposal Facility (CDF) known as Dike 14 located along
the Lake Erie shoreline adjacent to the Cleveland Harbor East
Entrance Channel, or the Government-designated Offshore Disposal
Area (ODA) east of Dike 14 at the village of Bratenahl, Ohio,
also located along the Lake Erie shoreline.
- 2 -
Upon reviewing the bids received in response to the above-referenced solicitation, the Corps of Engineers awarded the
contract to B + B Dredging Company ("B + B") of Chicago,
Illinois, the operator and lessee of the COLUMBUS, a U.S.-flagged, self-propelled, self-loading hopper dredge which is to
perform the work in question. This vessel, formerly known as the
ESPERANCE III, was originally built in the United States in 1944
as a World War II Landing Ship Tank ("LST"). It was later sold
foreign, converted to a hopper dredge in a European shipyard, and
placed under Panamanian registry. In 1977, the vessel was
purchased by CDECO Maritime Construction, Inc., a Delaware
corporation, to be used by Roger J. Au & Son, Inc. for dredging
in the United States. Upon its reconversion in the United
States, the U.S. Coast Guard ("USCG") documented it as a vessel
of the United States on April 7, 1978, and although it was
entitled to engage in dredging in this country, due to its prior
foreign ownership its Certificate of Registry contained a
restrictive notation prohibiting it from engaging in the
coastwise trade. Subsequent legislative enactments enabled the
vessel to engage in the coastwise trade only for the purpose of
transporting "valueless" dredged material.
Lake Michigan, the second low bidder for the subject
contract, subsequently filed a protest with the Contracting
Officer of the Corps of Engineers and with the Small Business
Administration. It is the contention of Lake Michigan that the
material to be dredged out of Cleveland Harbor and the Cuyahoga
River has value and therefore the COLUMBUS is prohibited from
transporting it coastwise.
In support of its position, Lake Michigan has submitted the
following exhibits: (1) a copy of a letter from the President of
Lake Michigan authorizing counsel to act as their agent in this
matter; (2) a copy of the most current USCG Certificate of
Documentation for the COLUMBUS; (3) a copy of the Corps of
Engineers' Solicitation no. DACW49-97-B-0006, issued December 16,
1996; (4) a copy of the abstract of offers showing that Lake
Michigan submitted the second low bid for this contract; (5) maps
of Cleveland Harbor showing the location of Dike 14; (6) a copy
of Great Lakes Dredge & Dock Company v. Ludwig, 486 F.Supp. 1305,
1307 (W.D. N.Y. 1980), affirmed without opinion in 636 F.2d 1201
(2nd Cir. 1980); (7) a copy of the USCG Certificate of Registry
for the subject vessel when it was known as the ESPERANCE III;
(8) a copy of a report of survey done at the request of the prior
owner describing the characteristics of the vessel; (9) an aerial
photograph of the subject vessel circa February, 1978; (10) a
copy of USCG ruling letter 16713/31-3, dated September 20, 1977;
(11) a copy of selected portions of 46 U.S.C. App.
883; (12) a copy of Customs ruling letter 102961/102466/102173,
dated September 28, 1977; (13) a copy of an engineering study by
Erickson Engineering Associates upon which the aforementioned
Customs ruling letter was primarily based; (14) a copy of Customs
ruling letter 110063, dated April 12, 1989; (15) a copy of Pub.
L. 102-587, Title V, Subtitle E, 5501(a)(2), 106 Stat. 5084,
included as an annotation to 46 U.S.C. App. 292; (16) a copy of
a report from Enviromatrix, Inc., dated November 15, 1996; (17) a
report from Richard Peddicord, Ph.D., Director of Sediment
Management, EA Engineering, Science, & Technology, Inc., dated
March 21, 1997; (18) a copy of Customs ruling letter MD 3-89858
F, dated October 30, 1963; (19) a copy of Customs ruling letter
MS 216.131 H, dated October 21, 1963; (20) a copy of Customs
ruling letter 102787, dated April 20, 1977; (21) a copy of
Customs ruling letter 102782/102717,
- 3 -
dated April 26, 1977; (22) a copy of an article describing Burke
Lakefront Airport published by the City of Cleveland Planning
Commission in 1988; (23) a copy of an aerial view of Burke
Lakefront Airport; (24) a copy of an aerial map depicting the
proposed expansion of the City of Cleveland's Gordon Park
encompassing the area of Dike 14; (25) a copy of relevant
portions of a 1987 Cleveland Waterfront Master Plan Update issued
by the Ohio Department of Natural Resources and the Governor's
Task Force on the Waterfront; (26) a copy of the "Agreement
between the United States of America and the Cleveland-Cuyahoga
County Port Authority for Local Cooperation for a Contained Spoil
Disposal Facility at Site 14 in Cleveland Harbor, Ohio"; (27 &
28) copies of letters from Lake Michigan to the Corps of
Engineers proposing to purchase dredge material out of Dike 14;
(29) copies of documentation regarding the sale by the Corps of
Engineers of dredge material from a CDF in Toledo, Ohio; (30) a
copy of a pre-solicitation notice from the Corps of Engineers to
raise the existing easterly perimeter of Dike 14 using dredge
material previously deposited there; (31) a copy of page EA-5 of
the "Environmental Assessment for Lake Erie Littoral Drift
Nourishment at Bratenahl and Perkins Beach Cuyahoga County, OH",
dated February 7, 1985, from the Corps of Engineers; (32) a copy
of a letter dated August 3, 1982, from the U.S. Environmental
Protection Agency to the Corps of Engineers; (33) a copy of page
C20 of the Corps of Engineers' Manual, EM 1110-2-5026, entitled
"Beneficial Uses of Dredged Material", dated June 30, 1987; (34)
a report from Charles W. Hummer, Jr., Dredging and Environmental
Consultant, dated March 24, 1997.
Subsequent to Customs receipt on February 25, 1997, of
counsel's letter on behalf of Lake Michigan enclosing all of the
above exhibits with the exception of Exhibits 17 and 34, the
aforementioned documentation was promptly forwarded by Customs to
B + B's counsel by letter of the same date in order to afford
that party an opportunity to respond in kind to the allegations
raised therein. Exhibits 17 and 34, missing at the time of Lake
Michigan's original submission, were subsequently provided to
Customs and counsel to B + B by Lake Michigan's letter of March
31, 1997. Counsel to B + B responded to the entirety of Lake
Michigan's submission by its letter of May 13, 1997, enclosing 35
exhibits with the exception of one (Exhibit 24) which was
submitted to Customs and Lake Michigan's counsel by letter of May
16, 1997. It is the position of B + B that at the time the
subject dredge material is transported and unloaded, it has no
value and the COLUMBUS is therefore not prohibited from engaging
in the transportation in question.
In support of its position, B + B has submitted the
following exhibits: (1) a copy of Pub. L. 100-329; (2) a copy of
Pub. L. 102-587; (3) a copy of Customs ruling letter
102961/102466/ 102173, dated September 28, 1977; (4) a copy of
Great Lakes Dredge & Dock Company v. Ludwig, 486 F.Supp. 1305,
1307 (W.D. N.Y. 1980), affirmed without opinion in 636 F.2d 1201
(2nd Cir. 1980); (5) a copy of a facsimile transmittal header
sheet from the Corps of Engineers, dated May 8, 1997; (6) a copy
of a letter from Robert P. Murphy, Area Director for Government
Contracting, U.S. Small Business Administration, dated April 4,
1997; (7) a copy of a "Notice To Proceed" from the Corps of
Engineers, dated April 14, 1997; (8) a copy of the Corps of
Engineers' Supplement Number Two (1994) to: Cleveland Harbor,
Ohio Confined Disposal Project Letter Report, dated January 1987;
(9) a copy of 46 U.S.C. App. 883; (10) a copy of the "Final
Environmental Impact Statement Modifications To Dike 14 Confined
Disposal Facility
- 4 -
Cleveland Harbor Cuyahoga County, Ohio"; (11) a copy of a "Final
Environmental Impact Statement Harbor Maintenance and Confined
Disposal Facility Site 10B (15-Year) Cleveland Harbor, Cuyahoga
County, Ohio"; (12) a memorandum dated January 10, 1997, from
Scott Pickard, Environmental Compliance Officer, Corps of
Engineers; (13) a copy of a Public Notice, dated November 17,
1995, from the Corps of Engineers; (14) a copy of House of
Representatives Report 102-260, dated October 21, 1991; (15) a
copy of Customs Service Decision (C.S.D.) 89-107; (16) a copy of
C.S.D. 90-73; (17) a copy of Customs ruling letter 111412, dated
November 28, 1990; (18) a copy of Customs ruling letter 109831,
dated November 14, 1988; (19) a copy of Customs ruling letter
227126, dated September 21, 1996; (20) a copy of Customs Legal
Determination No. 80-0135, issued September 10, 1980; (21) a copy
of the Corps of Engineers' Solicitation no. DACW49-97-B-0006,
issued December 16, 1996; (22) a copy of a Corps of Engineers'
memorandum dated February 11, 1992, regarding the Toledo Harbor
Long-Term Dredged Material Management Plan - Phase 1 Report; (23)
a copy of "Beneficial Uses of Dredge Material-A Practical Guide"
- a report of a working group of the Permanent International
Association of Navigation Congresses, dated May 27, 1992; (24) a
report from Gahagan & Bryant Associates, Inc.; (25) a copy of an
e-mail from Teofilo D. Valerio, dated December 23, 1996; (26) a
copy of an e-mail from Mary E. Price, dated November 20, 1996;
(27) a copy of "Environmental Assessment For Lake Erie Littoral
Drift Nourishment At Bratenahl And Perkins Beach Cuyahoga County,
Ohio" prepared by the Corps of Engineers, dated February 7, 1985
and Appendixes EA-A and EA-B consisting of copies of letters from
the United States Department of the Interior, dated August 5 and
18, 1982, and October 11, 1983; copies of letters from the United
States Environmental Protection Agency, dated August 3 and
September 2, 1982; copies of letters from the Ohio Department of
Natural Resources, dated August 23 and September 27, 1982; a copy
of a letter from the City of Cleveland Planning Commission, dated
July 20, 1982; a copy of a letter from the Cuyahoga County
Regional Planning Commission, dated June 22, 1982; a copy of a
Public Notice from the Corps of Engineers, dated November 5,
1984; a copy of a letter from the Ohio Historic Preservation
Office, dated June 18, 1982, and copies of telephone
conversations relating to the aforementioned documents and maps
of the areas in question; (28); a copy of testimony from a
hearing before the Subcommittee on Merchant Marine of the
Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation, U.S. Senate,
on January 28, 1988; (29) a listing of the dredging contracts
performed by the subject vessel from 1978 to the present; (30) a
copy of Senate Report 100-327, dated May 4, 1988; (31) a copy of
the Corps of Engineers' Manual, EM 1110-2-5026, entitled
"Beneficial Uses of Dredged Material", dated June 30, 1987; (32)
a copy of Senate Report 102-260, dated October 21, 1991; (33) a
copy of a declaration from Dewitt Barlow, President of B + B;
(34) comments regarding Lake Michigan's ruling request to Customs
dated February 20, 1997; and (35) a copy of a letter from Stanley
W. Erken of B + B, dated March 11, 1997, to Mr. Henry Cavanaugh,
Assistant Administrator for Environmental Affairs, Department of
Port Control, Cleveland, Ohio.
Counsel to both Lake Michigan and B + B agree that the
COLUMBUS is not prohibited from engaging in the dredging to be
performed pursuant to the contract in question. Counsel further
stipulate that all points involved in the transportation of the
subject dredge material are points embraced within the coastwise
laws of the United States. The point of contention in this
- 5 -
matter is this vessel's eligibility to transport material dredged
from Cleveland Harbor and the Cuyahoga River to Dike 14 and the
ODA at Bratenahl. All parties agree that the resolution of this
case turns on whether the dredge material in question is
considered to have value for purposes of Customs administration
of the coastwise laws.
ISSUE:
Whether the dredge material transported between coastwise
points pursuant to the terms of the contract offered by the Corps
of Engineers as described above is "dredge material of value"
within the meaning of Pub. L. 102-587 and therefore constitutes
"merchandise" for purposes of 46 U.S.C. App. 883.
LAW AND ANALYSIS:
The coastwise law pertaining to the transportation of
merchandise, 27 of the Act of
June 5, 1920, as amended (41 Stat. 999; 46 U.S.C. App. 883,
often called the "Jones Act"), provides, in pertinent part, that:
No merchandise,... shall be transported by water, or by
land and water,
on penalty of forfeiture of the merchandise (or a
monetary amount up
to the value thereof as determined by the Secretary of
the Treasury, or
the actual cost of the transportation, whichever is
greater, to be recovered
from any consignor, seller, owner, importer, consignee,
agent, or other
person or persons so transporting or causing said
merchandise to be trans-
ported), between points in the United States...embraced
within the coast-
wise laws, either directly or via a foreign port, or
for any part of the trans-
portation, in any other vessel than a vessel built in
and documented under
the laws of the United States and owned by persons who
are citizens of
the United States...
Under the so-called "First Proviso" to 883:
...[N]o vessel of more than 200 gross tons (as measured
under chapter 143 of
title 46, United States Code) having at any time acquired
the lawful right to engage
in the coastwise trade, either by virtue of having been
built in, or documented under
the laws of the United States, and later sold foreign in
whole or in part, or placed
under foreign registry, shall hereafter acquire the right to
engage in the coastwise
trade. (Emphasis added)
Section 5 of Pub. L. 100-329 (102 Stat. 588, effective June
7, 1988), amended 46 U.S.C. App. 883 thereby authorizing the
COLUMBUS to transport valueless material and dredge material
regardless of whether it has value, between coastwise points.
Subsequent legislation
- 6 -
amending the dredging statute (46 U.S.C. App. 292) addressed
this vessel's eligibility to engage in the coastwise trade.
With respect to dredging, 1 of the Act of May 24, 1906 (34
Stat. 204; 46 U.S.C. App.
292), was amended by the Oceans Act of 1992 (Pub. L. 102-587,
5501(a)(1) and (2), 106 Stat. 5039, 5084-85, effective November
4, 1992) to not only provide, inter alia, that the coastwise
eligibility requirements (i.e., U.S.-build, ownership and
documentation) are applicable to vessels used as dredges as of
the effective date of that legislation, but also with specific
regard to the COLUMBUS it further provided:
...the vessel's certificate of documentation shall be
endorsed to
prohibit the vessel from engaging in the transportation
of
merchandise (except valueless material), including
dredge
material of value, between places within the navigable
waters
of the United States. (emphasis added)
The navigation laws administered by Customs, including 46
U.S.C. App. 883 and 292, apply to points in the territorial
sea, defined as the belt, three nautical miles wide, seaward of
the territorial sea baseline, and to points located in internal
waters, landward of the territorial sea baseline, in cases where
the baseline and the coastline differ. As noted above, the
transportation of dredge material in this case is between points
embraced within the coastwise laws.
THE POSITION OF LAKE MICHIGAN
With respect to the threshold question regarding the value
of the dredge material under consideration, Lake Michigan refers
to Customs ruling 102961/102466/102173, dated September 28, 1977
and the decision of the Federal District Court in Great Lakes
Dredge & Dock Company v. Ludwig, 486 F.Supp. 1305, 1307 (W.D.
N.Y. 1980), affirmed without opinion in 636 F.2d 1201 (2nd Cir.
1980), wherein the subject vessel was authorized to transport
polluted dredge material for disposal only. Consequently, Lake
Michigan proffers that if the dredge material now under
consideration is no longer polluted, or if its transportation is
for any purpose other than that of disposal, the subject vessel's
transportation of such material would exceed the scope of the
aforementioned administrative and judicial decisions. With
regard to the former, Lake Michigan, through its experts,
contends that the material being dredged is no longer polluted
under current State of Ohio Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)
guidelines and may be used for beneficial purposes such as
landfill. Lake Michigan cites prior Customs rulings (Exhibits
18, 19 and 20) in support of its proposition that under such
circumstances, dredge material so used would be deemed to have
value thereby rendering it merchandise for purposes of the
coastwise laws.
Further in regard to the use of dredge material as landfill,
Lake Michigan notes that the City of Cleveland has previously
built Burke Lakefront Airport on a former CDF used to dispose of
material dredged from Cleveland Harbor. With respect to the
dredge material to be trans- ported to Dike 14 pursuant to the
Corps of Engineers contract currently under consideration,
- 7 -
Lake Michigan asserts that the material is to be used as landfill
to expand an already existing recreational facility located
adjacent to Dike 14 within the City of Cleveland known as Gordon
Park. While contending that the local authorities in Cleveland
also have the authority to sell this
land to another party after completion of the CDF's use for
disposal, Lake Michigan acknowl- edges that the Ohio Revised
Code, which recognizes the value of submerged land, may prohibit
such a sale.
In addition to its use as landfill, Lake Michigan contends
that the subject dredge material has value due to its potential
use for construction purposes. To that end Lake Michigan has
submitted offers to purchase dredge material from Dike 14
stemming from a previous sale by the Corps of Engineers of dredge
material from a CDF in Toledo, Ohio. An example of a construc-
tion use suggested by Lake Michigan includes a project using the
material to raise the earth berm along the existing perimeter of
Dike 14 in order to expand the capacity of the facility.
Notwithstanding any of the possible future uses of dredge
material to be deposited in Dike 14 as discussed above, Lake
Michigan nonetheless points out that Dike 14 has already been
designated a beneficial wetland habitat by the Corps of
Engineers. Consequently, Lake Michigan asserts that the value of
the dredge material disposed therein is currently acknowledged by
that federal agency.
In regard to the material dredged from the Upper Cuyahoga
River and deposited at the ODA at Bratenahl, Lake Michigan
asserts that its use for beach nourishment is probative of its
having value. Lake Michigan states that this beneficial use is
already recognized by the Corps of Engineers.
THE POSITION OF B + B
B + B states that the COLUMBUS is entitled to transport
dredge material from the dredging sites in Cleveland Harbor and
the Cuyahoga River to Dike 14 and the ODA at Bratenahl for the
following reasons:
A. Customs ruling letter 102961/102466/102173, dated
September 28, 1977, authorizing the COLUMBUS to
transport valueless dredged material remains applicable and valid
since the dredged material from this project will be
disposed of in Dike 14 or in Lake, Erie just as it was
in 1978.
B. The 1980 federal district court decision in the Great
Lakes case remains valid and applicable for the same
reasons as in A above.
C. The Customs Service, in determining whether the COLUMBUS
is engaged in the coastwise transportation of
merchandise, should determine whether the dredged
material has value only at the time of the unloading which ends
the coastwise movement, and not at a later time.
- 8 -
D. Feasible and beneficial uses of dredged material require
lengthy advanced planning and management, and cannot be
determined at the time of the coastwise movement.
E. Congress, in Pub.L. 100-329 and Pub.L. 102-587,
authorized the COLUMBUS to continue to undertake the same
types of dredging and transportation projects that it had
undertaken prior to the legislation.
F. The current and previous owners of the COLUMBUS have
relied, in good faith, on the above-cited Customs
Service ruling, the Great Lakes case, and two federal statutes enacted in 1988 and 1992.
G. The Corps of Engineers has indicated no beneficial use
planned for the dredged material from this project. The
Corps of Engineers solicitation refers only to disposal
of the dredged material, and the Corps of Engineers committed in
the solicitation to allow a contractor to retain the
material if the contractor wished.
B + B emphasizes that the determination of value must relate
only to the dredged material produced in the Cleveland-Cuyahoga
project now under consideration, to the value of the dredged
material when it is unloaded from the COLUMBUS, and to specific
valuable uses already planned and predictable when the dredged
material is unloaded. It is suggested by B + B that possible,
but unproven, future uses of dredged materials many years in the
future, and after substantial remediation, cannot impute value to
the material at the time it is disposed of in Dike 14.
In addition, B + B urges Customs to consider the context in
which the Corps of Engineers deals with dredged material. It is
stated that the Corps of Engineers is required to dispose of many
millions of cubic yards of dredged material every year throughout
the country, including approximately 300,000-400,000 cubic yards
from the Cleveland-Cuyahoga project annually.
B + B states that the most expensive option for the Corps of
Engineers is to retain the dredged material in a CDF such as Dike
14 which it must build and maintain. B + B further states that
the Corps of Engineers would prefer to be able to dispose of the
dredged material elsewhere, either by dumping in Lake Erie or by
finding a beneficial use that does not require a CDF.
THE POSITION OF THE U.S. CUSTOMS SERVICE
At the outset we note that it is readily apparent that the
statutory amendments enacted subsequent to the prior Customs
rulings cited by both parties regarding the activities in
question, as well as the plethora of information contained within
the supporting documentation submitted by both parties in
interest (none of which was available to and consequently not
considered by Customs at the time of these rulings' issuance),
necessitates a de novo review of the record in its entirety with
specific regard to the current controlling authority as applied
to the undisputed facts
- 9 -
of this case. To that end it should be noted that Customs
rulings are issued only in response to a
specific set of facts. (19 CFR 177.1(d)(1)) Furthermore, no
person should rely on a ruling or assume the principles of that
ruling will be applied in connection with any transaction other
than as described in the ruling letter. (19 CFR 177.9(c))
In regard to the prior Customs rulings cited by the parties
in interest, it is significant to note that all of them predate
the most recent and most critical of the above-referenced
statutory amendments (Pub. L. 102-587). Of those rulings
addressing the coastwise transportation of dredge material, we
note that they collectively reflected Customs position that the
mere dumping of dredge material without any particular purpose
renders such material other than "merchandise" within the meaning
of 46 U.S.C. App. 883. Consequently, the transportation of
such material between coastwise points under those circumstances
could therefore be effected by a non-coastwise-qualified vessel.
(Lake Michigan Exhibits (18) Customs ruling letter MD 3-89858 F,
dated October 30, 1963; (19) Customs ruling letter MS 216.131 H,
dated October 21, 1963; and (20) Customs ruling letter 102787,
dated April 20, 1977)
The oft-cited 1977 ruling in question was issued in response
to a letter dated August 10, 1977, wherein the former owners of
the COLUMBUS, then known as the ESPERANCE III, inquired as to
Customs opinion with respect to its proposed transportation of
dredge material from a point in U.S. territorial waters in the
Great Lakes area to a CDF also within such waters pursuant to a
federal dredge contract awarded by the Corps of Engineers. In
reviewing this matter, Customs relied in large measure on an
August 9, 1977, opinion from Erickson Engineering Associates
(Lake Michigan's Exhibit 13) that the dredge material in question
was not only polluted, but also a liability to the U.S.
Government. Although the report listed potential, albeit
dubious, uses of polluted dredge spoil deposited within a CDF
(e.g., agricultural, wildlife habitats, construction, etc.), it
concluded that "...polluted spoil has no value in the present
term, and little chance of value due to fortuitous circumstances
in the foreseeable future."
Accordingly, by letter dated September 28, 1977 (Customs
ruling letter 102961/102466
/102173, Exhibits 12 and 13 of Lake Michigan and B + B,
respectively), Customs determined that the polluted dredge spoil
in question was not "merchandise" for purposes of 46 U.S.C. App.
883 and the subject vessel was therefore eligible to effect the
transportation in question. In reaching this determination, the
ruling provided, in pertinent part:
If material is transported from one point to another
within the ter-
ritorial jurisdiction of the United States and dumped
for the sole
purpose of disposing of it, the material will not be
considered
coastwise "merchandise" and its transportation will not
be con-
sidered coastwise trade. However, if material is
transported
from one point to another within the territorial
jurisdiction of
the United States for a purpose other than just
disposing of it,
such as for landfill, the material will be considered
"merchandise"
and its transportation will be deemed coastwise trade.
- 10 -
This ruling was subsequently challenged in U.S. District
Court for the Western District of New York by the only other
bidder for the project. The court upheld Customs decision in
this matter rejecting the plaintiff's claim that Customs
construction of the term "merchandise" (i.e., things of value)
was erroneous. (see Great Lakes Dredge & Dock Company v. Ludwig,
486 F.Supp. 1305, 1307 (W.D. N.Y. 1980), affirmed without opinion
in 636 F.2d 1201 (2nd Cir. 1980), cited as Exhibits 6 and 4 by
Lake Michigan and B + B, respectively).
Approximately eleven years after Customs was first presented
with the legality of the subject vessel's coastwise
transportation of dredge material, Customs was again requested to
consider the transportation of dredge material by the same
vessel. The issue presented was whether the vessel, now known as
the COLUMBUS, could engage in the coastwise transportation of
sand (deemed then to have commercial value) it had dredged which
was to be used for beach nourishment. However, Customs was
requested to render its decision in light of
5 of Pub. L. 100-329, effective June 7, 1988 (pp. 12-13 of Lake
Michigan's Exhibit 11, Exhibit 3 of B + B), which amended 46
U.S.C. App. 883 to authorize the COLUMBUS to transport
valueless material, and dredged material regardless of whether it
has value, between coastwise points. Pursuant to Customs ruling
letter 110063, dated April 12, 1989 (Lake Michigan's Exhibit 14),
Customs held that the coastwise transportation of dredged sand by
the COLUMBUS was in compliance with 46 U.S.C. App. 883, as
amended.
Additional legislative action on the part of Congress
further addressed the eligibility of the COLUMBUS to engage in
the transportation of dredge material. Pursuant to Pub. L. 102-587, Title V, Subtitle E, 5501(a)(2), 106 Stat. 5084, effective
November 4, 1992 (included in an annotation to 46 U.S.C. App.
292, on p. 2 of Lake Michigan's Exhibit 15, B + B's Exhibit 2),
the COLUMBUS is prohibited from transporting "dredge material of
value" between points embraced within the coastwise laws (a
distinction heretofore irrelevant given the provisions of Pub. L.
100-329 authorizing the COLUMBUS to transport dredge material
coastwise regardless of whether it had value).
With respect to the current maintenance dredging project
under consideration in Cleveland Harbor and the Cuyahoga River,
the first such instance in which Customs has been requested to
consider the ramifications of Pub. L. 102-587, we note the dearth
of controlling legal authority cited in the record interpretive
of the term "dredge material of value" as it is used in that
statute. The legislative history of both Pub. L. 100-329
("Dredge material can be classified as valuable or valueless,
depending on the nature of the product and its intended use." - B
+ B's Exhibit 30 at p. 4) and Pub. L. 102-587 (merely referencing
"valueless dredge material" without discerning what constitutes
such a commodity - B + B's Exhibit 32 at p. 19) are also
negligible in this regard. Consequently, we find the
documentation contained within the record from the Corps of
Engineers (the agency charged with annually conducting this and
other such dredge projects) addressing dredge material at length,
and cited and discussed by both Lake Michigan and B + B, to be
instructive in ascertaining whether the subject dredge material
is considered to have value within the context of this ruling.
- 11 -
Our review of the above-referenced Corps of Engineers
documentation therefore begins with their solicitation offer for
this project (Exhibits 3 and 21 of Lake Michigan and B + B,
respectively). The language contained therein fails to specify a
use of the subject material subsequent to its "disposal" (a term
to which we impart no significance beyond the act of off- loading
the subject dredge material from the vessel) in both Dike 14 and
the ODA at Bratenahl. However, as will be discussed more fully
below, this lack of specificity is not in and of itself
dispositive of the issue under consideration.
With regard to Lake Michigan's claim that the dredge
material to be deposited in Dike 14 will be landfill used for an
expansion of Gordon Park, we note that although the Corps of
Engineers has identified parks and recreation as a beneficial use
of dredge material containment sites (see p. 1-1 of Corps of
Engineers' Manual, EM 1110-2-5026, dated June 30, 1987, entitled
"Beneficial Uses of Dredged Material"; hereinafter referred to as
the "manual"; Exhibits 31 and 33 of Lake Michigan and B + B,
respectively), the Corps of Engineers nonetheless states that
such use of dredged material containment sites "...requires
sound, careful planning..." (Id. at p. 11-1; See also Exhibit 23
of B + B supporting B + B's contention that such use of dredge
material requires lengthy advanced planning and management.) In
addition, the manual provides that of the many factors to be
considered in evaluating the use of such sites for recreational
purposes, those deemed important include "...the local or
regional demand and need for recreational facilities, the
interest and capability of local sponsors to participate in
development and operation, and available access." (see the
manual at p. 11-1) The documentary evidence submitted by Lake
Michigan in support of their claim in this regard includes a map
of the proposed expansion of Gordon Park, and pp. 37-38 of a 1987
Cleveland Waterfront Master Plan Update issued by the Ohio
Department of Natural Resources and the Governor's Task Force on
the Waterfront (Lake Michigan Exhibits 24 and 25). Both indicate
an incorporation into the park's land base of Dike 14 as well as
the construction of a breakwater "finger" to control waves and
water surge in Gordon Park's marina. In addition, Lake
Michigan's experts state that the level of contaminants contained
within the dredge material to be placed in Dike 14 does not
preclude its use for landfill, construction, or other beneficial
purposes. (Lake Michigan Exhibits 17 and 34)
In response to Lake Michigan's position that Dike 14 will be
used to expand Gordon Park, B + B cites to a letter from the
Cleveland Waterfront Coalition, dated November 6, 1989, to the
Corps of Engineers regarding the raising of the berm of Dike 14
to provide additional interim fill capacity until a new CDF is
available (Exhibit 10 of B + B). As noted by B + B, this letter
expresses opposition to raising the height of Dike 14 because it
delays any possible park expansion. The letter states that Dike
14 was constructed adjacent to Gordon Park in 1976 and was
"envisioned by local officials as a way to reclaim some of the
acreage lost due to the construction of Interstate 90." While it
provides that "a number of uses have been planned for the Dike 14
area including recreational facilities, parking, fishing piers,
picnic areas,...even swimming pools," it nonetheless expresses
concern about "the very nature of building public park facilities
on top of polluted dredgings."
- 12 -
The above concerns of the Cleveland Waterfront Coalition
mirror those of the Corps of Engineers with respect to the use of
dredge material for construction and industrial/commercial
purposes. With specific regard to the use of dredge material for
landfill and CDFs, uses proffered by Lake Michigan, the Corps of
Engineers states that, "While there are a number of obvious
economic advantages to these types of beneficial uses, the
environmental aspects may be so disadvantageous that a project is
not feasible." (see the manual at p. 15-8) Lake Michigan has
provided no evidence on behalf of the City of Cleveland
corroborating the opinions of its experts with respect to whether
the use of dredge material in Dike 14 for recreational purposes,
let alone for landfill or construction purposes, is
environmentally feasible. Furthermore, although the Corps of
Engineers issued a construction contract on July 15, 1996, to
raise the existing easterly perimeter of Dike 14 using soil
borrow "excavated from the dredged sediment previously deposited
within the confined disposal facility" (Lake Michigan's Exhibit
30), that dredge material is not the material which is the
subject of the ruling request now under consideration.
In addition, we are unpersuaded that the building of Burke
Lakefront Airport in Cleveland on a closed CDF in 1947 is
probative of the beneficial use of dredge material deposited in
Dike 14 approximately 50 years later. The fact that dredge
material under certain circumstances can and has been used
beneficially for landfill and construction purposes is not in
dispute. The building of Burke Lakefront Airport concerned a
construction project using different dredge material deposited at
a different location for a different purpose four decades ago.
We also find the distinctions with respect to location and
material regarding a sale by the Corps of Engineers of dredge
material from a CDF in Toledo, Ohio (Lake Michigan's Exhibits 27,
28 and 29) to be equally problematic.
Furthermore, B + B cites to p. EIS-25 of the Corps of
Engineers' "Final Environmental Impact Statement Modifications To
Dike 14 Confined Disposal Facility Cleveland Harbor Cuyahoga
County, Ohio, September 1993 (B + B's Exhibit 10) which states
that "[w]hile conversion of Dike 14 into a public park is a
desirable goal, the primary purpose of the dike is to provide a
suitable and safe disposal facility." The next two sentences of
that paragraph provide as follows:
After Dike 14 is filled and capped, ownership and
responsibility
for its future use will be transferred to the city of
Cleveland. At
that point, any actions required to turn Dike 14 into a
public park
or other use will be the responsibility of the city of
Cleveland.
It is therefore our opinion that although the above-discussed documentation reveals a local interest in expanding
Gordon Park through the annexation of a dredge material-filled
Dike 14, the four exhibits submitted by Lake Michigan in support
of this proposition (Exhibits 17, 24, 25 and 34) do not evidence
the degree of local planning and capability to participate in the
development and operation of such a project to which the Corps of
Engineers refers. This, as well as the other potential uses of
the dredge material to be deposited in Dike 14 suggested by Lake
Michigan, is tenuous.
- 13 -
Accordingly, we conclude that the record is insufficient to
establish that the material to be dredged from Cleveland Harbor
and deposited in Dike 14 has value for those future uses
proffered by Lake Michigan.
Notwithstanding our above determination, however, we
nonetheless refer to p. C-20 of Appendix C of the aforementioned
manual, entitled "Examples Of Beneficial Use Development On
Dredged Material Sites In North American Waterways*". Dike 14 is
listed therein as a project or site already designated by the
Corps of Engineers to be of beneficial use for "Habitat
development" (a beneficial use discussed at length in Chapter 4
of the manual). Further in this regard, a more recent (September
1993) evaluation of Dike 14 by the Corps of Engineers is
contained on p. EIS-19 of B + B Exhibit 10 which provides, in
pertinent part, as follows:
3.2.2 Natural Resources - Dike 14 presently exists as
an enclosed area
composed of various vegetative habitats. To date, the
entire 88 acres
of the CDF have been converted to man-made wetlands
which are in
the early successional stage of upland habitat...A mix
of open field and
upland vegetation is expected to continue to exist
until the disposal
facility is filled, at which time it will be developed
into a recreational
area to be tied in with Gordon Park. (Emphasis added)
Accordingly, the above documentation is conclusive evidence
of Lake Michigan's claim that the dredge material to be placed in
Dike 14 currently has value for the propagation of an existing
wetland habitat site recognized as a beneficial use of dredge
material by the Corps of Engineers. Regardless of the
speculative nature of any future use of this material, Customs
declines to contradict this formal acknowledgment by the Federal
agency having jurisdiction over its management.
In regard to Lake Michigan's claim that beach nourishment
is a beneficial use of dredge material, we note that such a use
is also recognized by the Corps of Engineers (see Chapter 9 of
the manual), a working group of the Permanent International
Association of Navigation Congresses (B + B's Exhibit 23), and B
+ B (see pp. 13-14 of B + B's letter of May 13, 1997)
notwithstanding the latter's position that the dredge material
under consideration to be dumped at Bratenahl is of questionable
benefit.
With respect to the current use of dredge material taken
from the section of the Upper Cuyahoga River specified in the
solicitation offer (Station 812+00 to 821+00) and placed at the
ODA at Bratenahl, Lake Michigan contends that such material is
clean sand suitable for such near-shore disposal citing an August
3, 1982, letter from the United States Environmental Protection
Agency (Lake Michigan's Exhibit 32 and contained within Appendix
EA-A of B + B's Exhibit 27). We note that the Corps of Engineers
has historically recognized the value of the placement of dredge
material at Bratenahl for purposes of beach nourishment as
opposed to the economically unfeasible alternative of purchasing
sand commercially and trucking it to that location where it would
have to be dumped and spread so as to be accessible to wave
action.
- 14 -
(See p. EA-5 of the "Environmental Assessment For Lake Erie
Littoral Drift Nourishment At Bratenahl And Perkins Beach
Cuyahoga County, OH" prepared by the Corps of Engineers, dated
February 7, 1985; and Appendix EA-A cited as Exhibits 31 and 27
by Lake Michigan and B + B, respectively)
Notwithstanding the apprehensions of the Ohio Department of
Natural Resources as to the effectiveness of placing dredge
material from the Upper Cuyahoga River at Bratenahl (see their
letters to the Corps of Engineers dated August 23 and September
27, 1982, contained within B + B's Exhibit 27), we note the
inclusion of a letter dated August 24, 1984, in Appendix EA-A of
B + B's Exhibit 27, from the United States Environmental
Protection Agency, to the Corps of Engineers stating that, "The
bottom sediments from stations 821 to 813 are predominantly clean
sands and of acceptable quality for littoral disposal."
Furthermore, the Corps of Engineers as recently as the Spring of
1996 has continued to use dredge material obtained from this same
area of the Upper Cuyahoga River for beach nourishment at
Bratenahl. We note that p. 2 of a Public Notice of the Corps of
Engineers regarding maintenance dredging and dredged material
discharge on the Cuyahoga River in 1996 (Exhibit 13 of B + B)
provides, in pertinent part:
Shoal material between approximate Station 821+10
(upstream
channel limit) downstream to approximate Station
815+00...is
predominantly sands and is suitable for littoral drift
nourishment.
The majority of the material dredged from this reach
during the
spring phase will be placed at the existing nearshore
disposal
facility at Bratenahl...
Furthermore, with respect to the material to be dredged from
this section of the Upper Cuyahoga River, we note the statement
of B + B's expert that, "Based on the general physical
characteristics of the dredged material from this area, the sandy
material could be used marginally as a beach nourishment fill,
provided the Corps of Engineers requires the proper techniques
and procedures for such use, and issues permits and offers such
an option." (See p. 4 of Exhibit 24 of B + B) Notwithstanding
this conditional acknowledgment of the beneficial use of this
material, the remainder of the record does not corroborate the
contention that the aforementioned provisional requirements are a
condition precedent for the subject dredge material to be deemed
to have value for purposes of beach nourishment. The record is
probative of the fact that since the mid-1980's and as recently
as the Spring of 1996, the Corps of Engineers, with the
concurrence of the United States Environmental Protection Agency,
has determined that material dredged from the same section of the
Upper Cuyahoga River that is specified in the Corps of Engineers'
solicitation offer currently under review is suitable for beach
nourishment at Bratenahl and in fact has been so used. The
record is devoid of any scintilla of evidence suggesting either
that the dredge material to be deposited at Bratenahl pursuant to
the current solicitation offer will be placed there for any other
purpose, or that it has restrictions placed upon its use that
would render it valueless at the time it is so deposited.
- 15 -
Accordingly, we find the subject dredge material transported
from the Upper Cuyahoga River (Station 812+00 to 821+00) to the
ODA at Bratenahl pursuant to the terms of the solicitation offer
of the Corps of Engineers to have value for purposes of beach
nourishment.
HOLDING:
The dredge material transported between coastwise points
pursuant to the terms of the contract offered by the Corps of
Engineers as described above is "dredge material of value" within
the meaning of Pub. L. 102-587 and therefore constitutes
"merchandise" for purposes of 46 U.S.C. App. 883. Its
coastwise transportation aboard the COLUMBUS therefore
contravenes 46 U.S.C. App. 883.
Sincerely,
Jerry Laderberg
Acting Chief
Entry and Carrier Rulings Branch